There are three ways to travel from my apartment to Jerusalem’s Old City or the Central City: walk through East Jerusalem, walk through Me’a She’arim, or take the bus. East Jerusalem is a set of Arab neighborhoods and Me’a She’arim is an ultra-Orthodox (Heredi) Jewish neighborhood (see my earlier blog entry “General impressions of Jerusalem”).
The web site of the U.S. State Department has a set of
warnings for traveling in Israel, the West Bank and Gaza (http://travel.state.gov/travel/cis_pa_tw/tw/tw_922.html). At one point the State Department advised U.S. citizens to avoid East Jerusalem. I commonly hear people in Jerusalem talk about avoiding East Jerusalem, it is spoken of in the same way as inner-city neighborhoods (e.g. the South Side of Chicago, the South Bronx, East L.A.). Currently the State Department advises “American citizens should take into consideration that public buses, trains, and their respective terminals are ‘off-limits’ to U.S. Government personnel.” In theory this leaves one route for traveling into the city, walking through Me’a She’arim. The reality however is that I feel most vigilant, most apprehensive, and most unsafe when walking through Me’a She’arim.
Nearly 200 years old, Me’a She’arim s the second oldest neighborhood outside the old city. It is populated by Heredi Jews who belong to one of many (over 100) Chasidic sects. At the edges of the neighborhood are signs advising women about to enter to wear “modest clothes." In the center of the neighborhood, where the first homes were built are additional signs requesting tour groups to not enter. Frankly I’m conflicted about the right of the neighborhood residents to make these requests or demands. On one hand these are public streets and no other neighborhood in Jerusalem has such restrictions. On the other hand, I’m not sure that I would want tourists frequenting my neighborhood and treating me like a novelty.
More central to my point though is how it feels to walk through Me’a She’arim as opposed to East Jerusalem. East Jerusalem is clearly an Arab neighborhood, there are often no sidewalks, the streets are in disrepair, there are primarily Arab men on the street and it is crowded. That is not to say women and youth are absent from the street, only that the majority of those on the street are men. While the residents look at me as I walk through, every shopkeeper has been cordial and ingratiating. When I first arrived, because of the State Department warnings and others’ comments I felt apprehensive walking through East Jerusalem. However, now I am as comfortable in East Jerusalem as I am in almost any other neighborhood.
Me’a She’arim has sidewalks and paved streets, in the oldest parts of the neighborhood many of these streets are quite narrow. In the late afternoon the streets are crowded with men wearing traditional dress (the clothing for men varies depending on the sect to which they belong) and women pushing strollers along with a gaggle of children. The children often stare at me as I walk by. I interpret the children’s affect as either scared or hostile. Men avoid eye contact and sometimes shield their eyes from me, as if I was walking nude through the neighborhood. I make a conscious attempt to stay out of people’s way and to avoid looking at the women. I feel, look and am treated as an outsider in Me’a She’arim. I'll also add that both my wife and daughter had stronger reactions to Me'a She'arim than I did, neither wanted to walk through even the edges of the neighborhood whereas they had no qualms about traversing East Jerusalem.